Critical Compendium » History
The Naming of America, by John W. Hessler

“It lurks in the background of our childhood imagination, now and again roaring back in adulthood to remind us of possibilities. A map of the world, that fixture in elementary classrooms, has always been a book masquerading as a flat piece of paper. Like layers of the earth for geologists, maps offer a glinting sample of the past. And when it comes to the Waldseemüller map, the Universalis Cosmographia that forms the subject of The Naming of America by John W. Hessler, there are earth-shattering discoveries to be found. Let it be said, up front, that The Naming of America is not a popular work in the vein of Doris Kearns Goodwin or Stephen Ambrose. Hessler’s is a scholarly affair, impeccably printed, where the footnotes are as long as the text, and controversies are discussed with dry impartiality.” Read the review at the California Literary Review.

Filed under: History, Nonfiction | Posted 04.15.08 | Comments: None

Marching Toward Hell: America and Islam After Iraq, by Michael Scheuer

“Unfortunately, Scheuer’s new book, “Marching Toward Hell,” grandiloquently and somewhat misleadingly subtitled “America and Islam After Iraq,” has all the weaknesses of his earlier works with almost none of their strengths. Scheuer appears to be frustrated by the fact that his analysis was not adopted by the Bush administration. Instead of thinking that this was due to honest disagreements or to legitimate policy constraints, Scheuer believes that darker forces are at play — stupidity at best, but possibly even treason, a charge Scheuer stops just short of making against the neoconservatives on a number of occasions.” Read the review at the New York Times.

Filed under: History, Nonfiction | Posted 03.17.08 | Comments: 1 Comment

The Man Who Made Lists: Love, Death, Madness, and the Creation of Roget’s Thesaurus, by Joshua Kendall

“The “categorical imperative” means something quite different, but it does sound like the right term for the self-protective psychological urge that drove Peter Mark Roget (1779-1869), creator of the Thesaurus, to classify and categorize all manner of things over a long lifetime. Madness did not just run in his family; it galloped, sped, sprinted, dashed and made haste. If the title of Joshua Kendall’s fine new biography of Roget has a clinical Oliver Sacks feel, the material pretty much justifies it. “The Man Who Made Lists” outlines the “chronic mental instability” of Roget’s maternal grandmother; the “psychotic trance” in which his mother spent her last days after a life of neurotic “neediness”; the breakdowns undergone by Roget’s sister and daughter (he married late and was widowed early); and the grief-driven, throat-slashing suicide of his uncle, the great British civil libertarian Samuel Romilly, who expired in Roget’s blood-soaked arms.” Read the review at the New York Times.

Filed under: Biography, History, Nonfiction | Posted 03.17.08 | Comments: None

Comedy at the Edge: How Stand-Up in the 1970s Changed America, by Richard Zoglin

“Call it the Gang Theory of history: the idea that a number of charismatic revolutionaries coalesce and together grab power and attention, overturn orthodoxies and remake their time . . . Richard Zoglin’s “Comedy at the Edge” is a work of Gang Theory that isn’t, alas, in their league. Through profiles of a dozen leading comedians, including George Carlin, Richard Pryor, Steve Martin, Robin Williams, Andy Kaufman and Jerry Seinfeld, Zoglin seeks to portray the rich stand-up subculture that flourished in the 1970s.” Read the review at the New York Times.

Filed under: History, Humor, Nonfiction | Posted 03.17.08 | Comments: None

Fortune’s a River: The Collision of Empires in Northwest America, by Barry Gough

“Fortune’s a River – The Collision of Empires in Northwest America is an excellent, exhaustively researched book that offers reading only for the stout hearted among us or those who never quite got enough of wading through factual texts in college. Author Barry Gough tackles the labyrinthine subject of how British Columbia became British Columbia and part of present day Canada while Oregon, Washington and Alaska eventually wound up as part of the United States.” Read the review at the California Literary Review.

Filed under: History, Nonfiction | Posted 03.12.08 | Comments: None

Luck and the Irish, by R.F. Foster

“R.F. Foster, the eminent Irish historian and biographer of Yeats, opens “Luck and the Irish” (Oxford University Press, 228 pages, $30), his pithy survey of recent Irish history, with a blizzard of statistics on the economic boom known as the Celtic Tiger.” Read the review at the New York Sun.

Filed under: History, Nonfiction | Posted 03.03.08 | Comments: None

American-Made: The Enduring Legacy of the WPA, by Nick Taylor

“Imagine the vista that a newly elected President Franklin D. Roosevelt surveyed from the oval office in March of 1933. From sea to shining sea, approximately 25% of the nation’s workers were unemployed. 25%. Since the stock market crash in October of 1929, the Depression had become a quicksand, pulling tens of millions into joblessness and uncertainty. And each person in these statistics had a family to feed, or a life interrupted, or a skill gone unused. The incredible tale of how the United States dragged itself up from this pit of despair, lurching and stumbling at times but forever going forward, is told in Nick Taylor’s brilliant new book American-Made.” Read the review at the California Literary Review.

Filed under: History, Nonfiction, Politics | Posted 03.03.08 | Comments: None

Almost a Miracle, by John Ferling

“John Ferling toiled for years in relative obscurity at West Georgia University, churning out at least nine books, dozens of articles, and uncounted reviews, almost all dealing with war and politics in eighteenth-century America, the same subjects that have brought fame and riches to Joseph Ellis, David Hackett Fischer, and David McCullough. His prose may lack the elegance of Ellis’s or McCullough’s, and he may not have plumbed the depths of manuscript evidence as Fischer has done, but his work is solid–clear, sensible, and intellectually nourishing. His most recent book, a 575-page, detailed narrative of the American Revolutionary War, is a personal masterpiece.” Read the review at Michigan War Studies Review.

Filed under: History, Military history, Nonfiction | Posted 02.29.08 | Comments: None

Mr. and Mrs. Prince, by Gretchen Holbrook Gerzina, researched with Anthony Gerzina

“Gretchen Holbrook Gerzina went looking for an African-American Yankee with a royal name, locally famous for performing ballads and arguing for her rights in court. In the case of Lucy Terry Prince, the recoverable truth is limited, but it still has more drama than the sketchy legend. The story starts with Prince’s husband, Abijah, born in 1706 and slave to several masters in New England, including an ancestor of the author. Abijah took advantage of several moves and military service: by the age of 45 he had negotiated, and probably bought, his freedom. Passing regularly through the frontier crossroads of Deerfield, Mass., he noticed Lucy, a veteran of the Middle Passage, who recited to customers at her owner’s tavern the only poem of hers that has survived.” Read the review at the New York Times.

Filed under: History, Nonfiction | Posted 02.27.08 | Comments: 1 Comment

In Search of the Blues, by Marybeth Hamilton

“In Search of the Blues” is not about the blues, or the people who made the blues. It’s about people who made the dark side of blues music into what popular mythology calls “the Delta blues.” Those people aren’t singers or players but folk song scholars and record collectors. So Marybeth Hamilton believes. She organizes her book around the personal stories of five people or groups of people. The first three — Howard Odum, Dorothy Scarborough, and John and Alan Lomax — are scholars. The last two groups — Frederic Ramsey, Charles Edward Smith and William Russell, followed by James McKune and the acolytes called the Blues Mafia — are collectors. Most of the scholars are older. The collectors are more obsessed.” Read the review at the New York Times.

Filed under: History, Nonfiction | Posted 02.27.08 | Comments: None

Sarah Johnson’s Mount Vernon, by Scott E. Casper

“In Sarah Johnson’s Mount Vernon, historian Scott E. Casper lays bear the unique narrative of America’s first sacred shrine, capturing the dizzying complexity of an early American community largely unrecognized and misunderstood. After all, Mount Vernon, writes Casper, is “a story not just of Washingtons but also of black people named Parker and Smith, Johnson and Ford.” Read the review at the Christian Science Monitor.

Filed under: History, Nonfiction | Posted 02.25.08 | Comments: None

Blood and Rage: A Cultural History of Terrorism, by Michael Burleigh

“Terrorist violence is often seen as violence for the sake of violence, death for the sake of perverse pleasure. Some of it no doubt is. In Michael Burleigh’s Blood and Rage, we meet many depraved killers. There is Sergei Nechaev, the 19th-century Russian nihilist, Carlos the Jackal, the loyalist Shankill Butchers. One of Burleigh’s aims is to strip terrorists of any spurious glamour that might be conferred on them by the other target of his book - the dangerously deluded liberal elite who apparently dominate the British media and politics - and in this he largely succeeds. Yet terrorists act for more complex motives than sadism or a love of violence. Burleigh calls terrorists ‘morally insane’ and believes that modern Islamic terrorism is ‘an existential threat to the whole of civilisation’. I am not sure that either statement is helpful in understanding such a difficult and often impenetrable phenomenon.” Read the review at the Guardian.

Filed under: History, Nonfiction, Politics | Posted 02.25.08 | Comments: None

The New Cold War, by Edward Lucas

“Should the British government, seemingly isolated, be standing up to the Kremlin and banging its drums so loudly about what President Vladimir Putin and his friends are up to? Surely these are the same Russians who have been pouring money (”laundering” might be the right word?) through the City; they own Belgravia, seemingly love our public schools and yet, here is Edward Lucas claiming we face a new cold war.” Read the review at the Guardian.

Filed under: History, Nonfiction, Politics | Posted 02.25.08 | Comments: None

Inheriting the Trade, by Thomas DeWolf

“Thomas DeWolf was 47 before he made a horrifying discovery: An ancestor of his, James DeWolf, was the head of the most successful slave-trading family in American history. The DeWolfs financed 88 voyages which carried about 10,000 enslaved Africans to the New World – and in the process became one of New England’s most wealthy and powerful families. Talk about having a skeleton in the closet. The only slightly mitigating factor was the fact that Thomas did not descend directly from James; James was instead the nephew of Thomas’s direct ancestor, who was a carpenter from Connecticut. But that bit of distance wasn’t enough to cancel out the shame now associated with the name DeWolf.” Read the review at the Christian Science Monitor.

Filed under: History, Memoir, Nonfiction | Posted 02.25.08 | Comments: None

The Dress of the People: Everyday Fashion in 18th-Century England, by John Styles

“There’s been an academic argument at least since EP Thompson wrote The Making of the English Working Class 45 years ago, over the degree to which the material world of labouring Englishmen and women enlarged, improved and was fashion-inspired between the end of the 17th century and the 1832 Reform Act. John Styles is a moderate in the debate, balanced between the optimists who believe that the gratification of the wants of the low-waged almost precipitated the industrial revolution and the pessimists who claim, to borrow a cracking line from Thompson, that the majority of the lowly got only “a few articles of cotton clothing … and a great many articles in the Economic History Review.” Read the review at the Guardian.

Filed under: History, Nonfiction | Posted 02.25.08 | Comments: None

Custerology: The Enduring Legacy of the Indian Wars and George Armstrong, by Michael A. Elliott

“No sooner had I finished reviewing Michael Wallis’s recent biography of Billy the Kid for this journal than what should come in the next day’s mail but Michael Elliott’s excellent new book Custerology, about that other hardy perennial of western legend, sometime General George Armstrong Custer, who with more than 250 men of the Seventh Cavalry, which he commanded, met his death in the Battle of the Little Bighorn, in southern Montana, on the afternoon of June 25, 1876.” Read the review at New York Review of Books.

Filed under: Biography, History, Nonfiction | Posted 02.20.08 | Comments: None

The Teapot Dome Scandal, by Laton McCartney

“To most Americans younger than, say, 50, the Watergate scandal is a vague affair. Oh sure, they know that it involved a break-in and cost Richard M. Nixon the presidency. But past that, the names and details are fuzzy at best. That historical blank spot may surprise those older Americans who vividly recall Judge Sirica, Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein, and all the rest. But these same older Americans have a similarly vague knowledge of the Teapot Dome Scandal — even though it made headlines throughout the 1920s, brought down Cabinet members, produced several corpses and exposed a corrupt government that had sold out to Big Oil. Now comes writer Laton McCartney, determined to introduce new generations to the details of Teapot Dome. His subtitle sums up his approach: “How Big Oil Bought the Harding White House and Tried to Steal the Country.” Read the review at the St. Louis Post-Dispatch.

Filed under: History, Nonfiction, Politics | Posted 02.19.08 | Comments: None

Did Lincoln Own Slaves? by Gerald J. Prokopowi

“It is good to have this book arrive near the head of the stream of publications certain to appear as we approach the bicentennial next year of Abraham Lincoln’s birth. Most of the books to come will treat only one phase of Lincoln’s life or focus on a particular aspect of his life and work. “Did Lincoln Own Slaves?” has no such limits, as it treats in question-and-answer style matters on the minds of curious folks wanting to know more about the man regarded by many as our nation’s greatest president. Read this book, and you will be an informed reader of the others, and even if you don’t read other ones, you will still be equipped to engage knowledgeably in conversations about Lincoln.” Read the review at the St. Louis Post-Dispatch.

Filed under: Biography, History, Nonfiction, Politics | Posted 02.19.08 | Comments: None

Byzantium: The Surprising Life of a Medieval Empire, by Judith Herrin

“It is spoken of in fiction and histories as an enigma, a shrouded maze of privileged deception and perfumed deceit, an ossified, jewel-encrusted court, where guile and honeyed treachery reign – a medieval Middle Eastern version of the Versailles of Louis XV. It is Byzantium. But that image, as cinematically enticing as it may be, is one of the most effective examples of disinformation the world has ever seen, as Judith Herrin reveals in her remarkable new history, Byzantium: The Surprising Life of a Medieval Empire.” Read the review at the Christian Science Monitor.

Filed under: History, Nonfiction | Posted 02.13.08 | Comments: None

Vermeer’s Hat: The Seventeenth Century and the Dawn of the Global World, by Timothy Brook

“Stories of ethnic cleansing, human trafficking and illegal immigration, of corporate power and the uneven effects of free trade have become so prevalent as to define our understanding of the post-Cold War world. But, as Timothy Brook shows in his elegant and quietly important book, such stories have been with us for centuries, and our global world is much older than we typically think.” Read the review at the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel.

Filed under: History, Nonfiction | Posted 02.12.08 | Comments: None

The Mighty Wurlitzer, by Hugh Wilford

“It has been decades since the late historian Christopher Lasch wrote his famous essay “The Cultural Cold War” in the Nation, which showed that many postwar American intellectuals had accepted funds from the CIA, and argued that they were as compromised as those artists and intellectuals in Europe and those within the Soviet bloc who prospered by accepting KGB sponsorship. With “The Mighty Wurlitzer” (Harvard University Press, 342 pages, $27.95), Hugh Wilford has given us the first comprehensive and thorough report of how the CIA — modeling its policies on the Comintern’s creation of Communist front groups — created their own fronts, with recipients who included not only the white male writers and artists who made up much of the postwar cultural establishment, but women, African-Americans, students, the labor movement, Catholics, and journalists.” Read the review at the New York Sun.

Filed under: History, Nonfiction | Posted 02.11.08 | Comments: None

After Tamerlane, by John Darwin

In 1860, at the climax of the Second Opium War, a joint English and French army marched on Peking and burned the imperial summer palace to the ground. It was the most dramatic possible demonstration of the accelerating superiority, military and financial, of Europe over the rest of the world. China was far larger in territory and population than either France or England, yet the thought of a Chinese force storming Buckingham Palace was self-evidently absurd. The Middle Kingdom had no choice but to submit to the Western powers’ demands, giving their merchants and missionaries the right to move freely throughout the country. For the Chinese — who still dominated East Asia, and enjoyed an unbroken cultural tradition much older than Europe’s — it looked as though the world had been turned upside down. “We are shamefully humiliated,” lamented a Chinese scholar quoted by John Darwin in his exceptionally wide-ranging new history, “After Tamerlane” (Bloomsbury, 592 pages, $34.95).” Read the review at the New York Sun.

Filed under: History, Nonfiction | Posted 02.11.08 | Comments: 1 Comment

Artists in Exile: How Refugees From Twentieth-Century War and Revolution Transformed the American Performing Arts, by Joseph Horowitz

“It is hard to imagine where American culture would be today without the contributions of Hitler and Stalin — that is, without the thousands of creatively gifted refugees who fled these murderers. A good many cultural historians and writers have explored this meaty subject from different angles since Anthony Heilbut’s 1983 landmark, “Exiled in Paradise” (still the best book on the topic). And now, in “Artists in Exile,” Joseph Horowitz has taken a crack at it. Horowitz, a former music critic for The New York Times and the author of seven previous books, including the superb trio “Understanding Toscanini,” “Wagner Nights” and “Classical Music in America,” is well versed in this subject.” Read the review at the New York Times.

Filed under: Art/aesthetics, History, Nonfiction | Posted 02.05.08 | Comments: None

Forgotten Continent: The Battle for Latin America’s Soul, by Michael Reid

“Michael Reid, a longtime Latin America correspondent and the editor of the fine Americas section of The Economist, takes exception to such benign neglect (of Latin America), and worse, in “Forgotten Continent: The Battle for Latin America’s Soul.” In a brilliantly researched and annotated work of scholarship, Reid makes a cogent case that the battle (for the continent) has become more internal — but of necessity, not by choice.” Read the review at the New York Times.

Filed under: History, Nonfiction, Politics | Posted 02.05.08 | Comments: None

Desparate Passage: The Donner Party’s Perilous Journey West, by Ethan Rarick

“Ethan Rarick, a journalist and the author of “California Rising: The Life and Times of Pat Brown,” takes up the story (of the Donner Party) in “Desperate Passage.” I suspect that the impetus for the book was the shift toward science that has taken place in the study of the Donner party in the past quarter-century. Archaeologists in the 1980s dug for evidence at what is now called Donner Lake, near the Sierra town of Truckee, where a majority of the party camped. In the past few years, another team has extracted artifacts from the meadow, seven miles away, where the Donner family itself lived in makeshift tents.” Read the review at the New York Times.

Filed under: History, Nonfiction | Posted 02.05.08 | Comments: None

The Wagner Clan, by Jonathan Carr

“Few modern human beings have claimed a status so godlike, and the philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche, an early friend and devotee of Wagner’s, soon became disgusted by the composer’s pretensions, likening the receptions at the first Bayreuth festival to “papal audiences.” But Nietzsche was only there to begin with because Wagner’s music — epic, enveloping and mystical — is capable of instilling quasi-religious feelings; he felt it too. After Wagner died, his family decided to match life to art. They turned up the idolatry to 11, carefully buffing all the ignominious aspects of his past out of official accounts, and presiding over the Bayreuth festival in a dynastic succession. Jonathan Carr’s fiendishly enjoyable “The Wagner Clan” describes the history of this dynasty, as plagued by scandal and treachery as the snarling millionaires in any prime-time soap opera.” Read the review at Salon.com.

Filed under: Biography, History, Nonfiction | Posted 02.04.08 | Comments: None

The Secret History of the World, by Mark Booth

“Christian Science and Scientology are among the very few “secret” societies whose beliefs Mark Booth doesn’t promise to unveil in his new book, “The Secret History of the World: As Laid Down by the Secret Societies,” but in this respect, at least, they fit right in. Booth, an editor at a British publishing house, presents his book as an alternate history of the cosmos and humankind, with the early chapters relating the creation of the world and later chapters devoted to all of crankdom’s usual suspects: “Egyptian” hermeticism, Neo-Platonism, the Knights Templar, the pineal gland, alchemy, Rosicrucianism, Freemasonry — you name it.” Read the review at Salon.com.

Filed under: History, Nonfiction | Posted 02.04.08 | Comments: None

The Telephone Gambit: Chasing Alexander Graham Bell’s Secret, by Seth Shulman

“Does the right person always get credit for a great invention? Was Thomas Edison or the Englishman Joseph Swan responsible for the light bulb? Did Al Gore or some other geek invent the Internet? Did Alexander Graham Bell steal from Elisha Gray a key idea behind the telephone? Such questions can fuel debates between historians of technology and champions of neglected genius. Science journalist Seth Shulman did not set out to tackle the Bell-Gray controversy, but a chance discovery made the challenge irresistible.” Read the review at the Washington Post.

Filed under: Biography, History, Nonfiction, Science | Posted 02.04.08 | Comments: None

Twilight at Monticello: The Final Years of Thomas Jefferson, by Alan Pell Crawford

“If you’re Joseph Ellis dissecting George Washington or David McCullough tackling John Adams, the answer isn’t so hard: You’re Joseph Ellis or David McCullough! But if you’re anyone else, you’d better have an angle. You can (A) write new stuff about an obscure founder: How Charles Pinckney Saved America! Or you can (B) unveil a lesser-known aspect of a famous founder: John Adams, Meticulous Gardener! The only other option (C) is to recast old material with some counterintuitive spin: George Washington’s Willing Executioners! In Twilight at Monticello, Alan Pell Crawford has chosen option B, compiling a well-researched narrative of Thomas Jefferson’s post-presidential years — with a notable non-emphasis on the best-known aspect of those years, Jefferson’s correspondence with Adams.” Read the review at the Washington Post.

Filed under: Biography, History, Nonfiction, Politics | Posted 02.04.08 | Comments: None

The Lodger Shakespeare: His Life on Silver Street, by Charles Nicholl

“(Charles) Nicholl has, in fact, been publishing books about aspects of the Renaissance for most of his literary career. They range from the youthful and technical The Chemical Theatre — about the use of alchemical lore in Elizabethan drama — to his recent Leonardo da Vinci: Flights of the Mind. He’s written about the search for El Dorado and, in a departure, about the African adventures of the poet-turned-gunrunner Arthur Rimbaud. Still, Nicholl remains best known as the author of The Reckoning, a thrilling re-creation of the life, world and death of Christopher Marlowe. As in the Marlowe book, The Lodger Shakespeare enhances our sense of a great dramatist’s work and world by looking at the people around him.” Read the review at the Washington Post.

Filed under: Biography, History, Nonfiction | Posted 02.04.08 | Comments: 1 Comment

Philosophers Behaving Badly, by Nigel Rodgers and Mel Thompson

“Philosophers may lead us in terms of profound ideas, but their personal lives can be quite another matter entirely. As historian Nigel Rodgers and philosopher Mel Thompson write in their marvelous little book, Philosophers Behaving Badly, “a life of reason does not necessarily lead to a reasonable life.” Their portraits of eight philosophers bring home this point again and again. Although monumental in their insights, these philosophers were screwed up!” Read the review at Philosophy Now.

Filed under: History, Nonfiction, Philosophy | Posted 02.02.08 | Comments: None

The Messenger: The meanings of the life of Muhammad, by Tariq Ramadan

“The Messenger cannot be considered an impartial historical biography in the Western tradition – still less an apology. Indeed, those familiar with the habitual points of Western interest in early Islam (which pretty much follows the tabloid code of sex and violence) will find Tariq Ramadan’s book a most frustrating document. Where are the pages devoted to the Prophet’s marriage to his child-bride, Aisha, or on his exemption from the limit of four wives placed on other believers, or on how the Prophet’s adopted son, Zayd, divorced his own wife, Zaynab, so that she could also join the household of Muhammad?” Read the review at the Times Literary Supplement.

Filed under: Biography, History, Nonfiction, Religion | Posted 02.02.08 | Comments: None

The Trojan War: A New History, by Barry Straus

“In his “New History,” Barry Strauss tells the story of the Trojan War from the very beginning. Paris, the “cosmopolitan prince” from Troy, abducted the unhappy Helen in Sparta, not for love but for political reasons. Strauss sees the adulterous couple as “less like Romeo and Juliet than Juan and Eva Péron.” Helen escaped Sparta, and Paris “carried out a bloodless raid on enemy territory.” The war ignited in this way between two mighty powers, Troy and Greece, had been looming for a long time because “Troy invites war.” Read the review at Michigan War Studies Review.

Filed under: History, Military history, Nonfiction | Posted 01.25.08 | Comments: None

Burning to Read: English Fundamentalism and its Reformation Opponents, by James Simpson

“In his provocative new study, “Burning to Read: English Fundamentalism and Its Reformation Opponents,” James Simpson undertakes a bold reassessment not only of Thomas More as embattled “defender of the faith,” but of the English Reformation itself. His focus is quite specific; he identifies the years 1520 to 1547 as crucial. Though Martin Luther had nailed his inflammatory 95 theses to the door of the Castle Church in Wittenberg on October 31, 1517, it was during these tumultuous later years that the Reformation established itself decisively in much of Britain.” Read the review at the New York Sun.

Filed under: History, Nonfiction, Religion | Posted 01.22.08 | Comments: None

The Ghost Mountain Boys, by James Campbell

“Sometimes you see it said in a fiction review that the geographical setting is as much of a character in the novel as, well, the characters. It seems this observation can be extended to nonfiction, as well, for in James Campbell’s superb “The Ghost Mountain Boys,” the island of New Guinea is one of the most fearsome characters you will ever want to come across, in fiction or real life. The Ghost Mountain Boys were the men of 2nd Battalion, 32nd Infantry Division, who made an appallingly grueling trek in late 1942 from near Port Moresby on the south coast of New Guinea, across the Owen Stanley Mountains, to do battle with the Japanese solidly entrenched at Buna on the north coast. Campbell, author of “The Final Frontiersman,” ably explains how they did it — they did it with excruciating difficulty. Why they ever were made to do it is another question entirely.” Read the review at the Denver Post.

Filed under: History, Military history, Nonfiction | Posted 01.18.08 | Comments: None

Stealing Lincoln’s Body, by Thomas J. Craughwell

“Thomas Craughwell, an independent writer who has specialized in Catholic history and American popular culture, devotes the long prologue of his book “Stealing Lincoln’s Body” to a succinct account of the circumstances of Lincoln’s assassination and then the lugubrious, black-crepe-draped journey from Washington, D.C., to Springfield via Chicago (1,654 miles) in a nine-car special train making stops in 10 cities for processions, public viewing of the coffin and local funeral ceremonies.” Read the review at the Chicago Tribune.

Filed under: History, Nonfiction | Posted 01.17.08 | Comments: None

Virtue and Terror, by Maximilien Robespierre

‘It is salutary to remember . . . that one of the defining moments in the development of modern politics, the French Revolution, involved the deliberate use of terror in the cause of liberty. While today’s political class might like to imagine that this was a case of the democratic revolution ‘going too far’, and that we have since gradually settled on a peaceful, ‘political’ way of resolving social conflicts, the ghostly voice of Maximilien Robespierre is a reminder that politics and violence are not so easily separated.’ Read the review at Spiked.

Filed under: History, Nonfiction | Posted 01.11.08 | Comments: None

This Republic of Suffering: Death and the American Civil War, by Drew Gilpin Faust

‘Amazon.com lists more than 36,000 books on the American Civil War, and my guess is that most of them depict battles and heroes, and describe wartime deaths as noble and tragic. Drew Gilpin Faust’s “This Republic of Suffering” does something different. It’s a shattering history of the war, focusing exclusively on death and dying — how Americans prepared for death, imagined it, risked it, endured it and worked to understand it.’ Read the review at the Los Angeles Times.

Filed under: History, Military history, Nonfiction | Posted 01.09.08 | Comments: 1 Comment

Churchill and the Jews: A Lifelong Friendship, by Martin Gilbert

‘Even Winston had a fault,’ Gen. Edward Louis Spears, a dear friend of Winston Churchill, once told historian Martin Gilbert. “He was too fond of Jews.” Spears’s remark, which rather neatly epitomized the pervasive anti-Semitism of Britain’s ruling class, is Gilbert’s jumping-off point for his sympathetic but ultimately disappointing account of the singularly warm and supportive relationship between the greatest British leader of the 20th century and the Jewish people.’ Read the review at the Washington Post.

Filed under: Biography, History, Nonfiction | Posted 12.20.07 | Comments: 1 Comment

Daughter of Heaven: The True Story of The Only Woman to Become Emperor of China, by Nigel Cawthorne

‘Let us imagine that the Emperor Wu Chao, female ruler of China during the 7th century (according to the Gregorian calendar) and Queen Elizabeth I, ruler of England during the 16th, meet in the afterlife. After exchanging gossip about Cleopatra’s latest exploits, talk turns to their unlikely ascents to power. While Elizabeth is sure that the execution of her ambitious mother Anne Boleyn, the death of her Protestant brother, and the machinations of her Catholic sister top any stories that Wu Chao can tell, she, as they say, ain’t heard nothing yet. The incredible adventure of Wu Chao is the premise of Nigel Cawthorne’s book, “Daughter of Heaven: The True Story of the Only Woman to Become Emperor of China.’ Read the review at the California Literary Review.

Filed under: History, Nonfiction | Posted 12.16.07 | Comments: None

A Farewell to Alms: A Brief Economic History of the World, by Gregory Clark

‘Why do some countries have an economically helpful culture while others don’t? And, since no society got very far in economic terms before the Industrial Revolution, what caused the culture of the recently successful ones to change? In “A Farewell to Alms,” Gregory Clark, an economic historian at the University of California, Davis, suggests an intriguing, even startling answer: natural selection.’ Read the review at the International Herald Tribune.

Filed under: History, Nonfiction, Science | Posted 12.14.07 | Comments: None

Power, Faith, and Fantasy: America in the Middle East, by Michael B. Oren

‘Oren posits that the Middle East has had a much greater influence on American identity and fortunes than is usually believed. It was the U.S. Navy’s 1815 victory over the pirates that won the country international respect and safeguarded its early trade. The American Board of Missions installed the modern educational institutions of the Turks and Arabs (e.g., the American College of Beirut), a by-product of an otherwise failed effort to convert Muslims and Jews (and other Christians) to varieties of Protestantism. After the Civil War, officers both Union and Confederate trained the Egyptian military. American engineers built a modern shipyard and armory for the Ottomans. And in the late 19th century the Middle East became a prime attraction for wealthy (and not so wealthy) American tourists.’ Read the review at the Claremont Review.

Filed under: History, Nonfiction | Posted 12.09.07 | Comments: